Lifting the ban on political ads is good for the left

In 1964, Lyndon Johnson set off a political phenomenon in America with an advert that set the Presidential elections alight. The opening shot of a young girl picking a daisy and counting down from ten, ends with a huge nuclear explosion and the voiceover: “These are the stakes: to make a world in which all of God’s children can live or go into the dark. We must either love each other, or we must die”.

The implication – that Johnson’s opponent, Barry Goldwater, would lead the world to nuclear holocaust wasn’t hard to see.

This advert is usually of interest to a few political insiders interested in the minutiae of US politics. But it could about to get interesting for anyone interested in winning hearts and minds of voters this side of the Atlantic. The High Court will today hear a case brought by a group of animal rights campaigners – and backed by the likes of Amnesty International and the RSPCA – to lift the ban on political advertising in the UK. According to yesterday’s Guardian, the ban is likely to be lifted – last year, the ECJ ruled against a Swiss ban very similar to ours.

I think this is a move that should be welcomed for two reasons. One of principle, and one of political practicalities.

Firstly on principle. The law as it stands bans advertising that seeks “to influence public opinion on a matter of controversy”. That leaves big businesses with a massive advantage over political campaigns. Asda Wal-Mart is free to persuade us that it is doing the right thing by everyone, opponents are not free to point out that it pays low wages and has been accused of exploiting workers. BP is free to promote its green credentials, green groups are banned from pointing out that this is a load of hot air. That’s just not right.

But on a more practical note, we have a message to get across that we are not always able to get through the gatekeepers of public morality – the media.

Make Poverty History had an advert banned last year. Apparently, education people about the deaths of millions of people around the world because of unfair international trade policies is too controversial for sensitive ears. Trade Unions have had political adverts banned from under noses too. The public is not now going to hear about these two issues in the way these organisations wanted them to.

Of course, there are right-wing groups who are licking their lips at the thought of being able to launch aggressive advertising campaigns too. North East Says No campaign’s political broadcast is possibly the best example of aggressive populism on our TV’s so far, and more will come if the advert ban is lifted.

But are we really that scared of the weakness of our own arguments?

Of course, if – and when – the ban is lifted, there will have to be a sensible framework of rules to make sure that rich organisations can’t just buy public opinion – but the fact remains, progressive organisations have a huge amount to gain from the lifting of this ban.

In 1964, Johnson’s ads painting Barry Goldwater as a dangerous right-wing extremist played a massive part in winning the Democrats a landslide victory. Using political ads is neither a right-wing nor a left-wing tool, but it is one we will be able to us to devastating effect if progressives can harness them correctly.


2 Responses to Lifting the ban on political ads is good for the left

  1. Nick says:

    I guess the question is whether this will or should be extended to political parties? And if not, how far you go in regulating against US-style arms length campaign groups that attack one side but deny co-ordinating with the party that benefits.

    I think there’s a very good case for saying that anything that is the subject of advertising already – as you say, companies can advertise on their environmental records – should be open to advertising that puts across a different view on the same issue.

    Whether you open this up to a complete free-for-all is, however, a rather different question. Should be an interesting one to watch.

  2. Jackie says:

    Thanks for your post, i am doing a study on this and you have gibven me some great info



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: